Firm and elegant, this red falls into the mineral camp, with a stony undertow to its cherry and strawberry flavors. Precise and balanced in a linear profile, with a lingering finish. Best from 2014 through 2023. 50 cases imported. -BS

Sour cherry, ginger, and hints of lily-like sweet perfume mingle with a rather detached sense of caramelized oak in the nose of Chauvenet’s 2008 Chambolle-Musigny. The unknit split between tart fruit and wood (40% of which was new) persists all across the palate, though there is still much to be said for the ultimate exuberance and invigorating sense of spice projected in the wine’s finish. I would want to revisit this sometime in 2011 to assess its potential past, say, the next 4-5 years. Hubert Chauvenet testified to normal malos (i.e. finishing in spring – the wines’ first spring that is!). He points to the bright red of his successful 2008s as witness to the health of the corresponding fruit, whereas the 2007s had by the same stage already taken on a hint of garnet, and he tends to agree with me that many 2007s – in which, naturally he did not include his own! – were at their most exuberant and expressive while still in cask. Vigilant canopy-management and aggressive fruit-dropping have long been constants here. Chauvenet’s cellar has now been arranged to permit delivery of his fruit to the fermentation vats via conveyor and to eliminate pumping, and the refinement of tannins and clarity of fruit I witnessed in the best of these 2008s – especially considering that their author still favors high levels of new wood – can almost surely be traced to those developments. And speaking of clarity, Chauvenet pointed out that several of his 2008s are on the edge of what he deems acceptable turbidity and unfortunately resisted naturally clarifying to any greater degree. But after due consideration, he decided to bottle, as usual, without filtration, a wise move I would guess, given how well these 2008s have turned out.Imported by Robert Kacher Selections, Washington, DC; tel. (202) 832 9083

The Chauvenet-Chopin 2006 Chambolle-Musigny (from an unpropitious site near the route nationale) is rather sour cherry- and cranberry-tart, with undertones of concentrated herbal and cherry pit bitterness pulling in a slightly tight, austere direction. Overtones of truffle and quarry dust add some fascination. This may benefit from a couple of years in bottle, but I would be cautious and purchase it only if one appreciates Pinot in a high-pitched and high-acid mode. Hubert Chauvenet professed having been more active than normal in 2006 with punch-downs and pump-overs, in order to compensate for paucity of material, and a certain undertone of bitterness in a few of his lighter-weight 2006s may be explicable on that account.Imported by Robert Kacher Selections, Washington, DC; tel. (202) 832 9083