This has plenty of very ripe red fruits, but at the same time the tannins push through, firm and dry, and, at this young stage, tough. It promises some good aging, with the wood element coming into balance.——R.V.(3/1/2008)—— 90

Shows some rustic spicy and herbal notes, along with strawberry and herbal tea flavors. Light in body, and a bit tart and tannic on the finish, this lacks the generosity shown by the other 2004 reds in the lineup.——W.E.(11/1/2006)—— 84

Shows the torrid vintage character in its aromas of chocolate fudge and flavors of dark plum and chocolate, but doesn’t go off into raisins or prunes. Finishes with coffee and dry toast notes that should eventually integrate. It’s a big, bulky, tannic wine that might improve over time.——J.C.(9/1/2006)—— 86