Revealing a dark ruby color, the 2005 Pinot Noir Estate possesses a totally different set of aromatics, with more spice, earth, cinnamon, and herb characteristics. In the mouth, it exhibits tart acidity, cherry and pomegranate fruit flavors, and a less complete, shorter finish. It is a less accessible, spicier, earthy example of Pinot than the 2004. It is not nearly as exciting as the 2004. Tel. (888) 865-9463

A welcome return to form after the disappointing ’04, Mount Eden’s ’05 shows refreshing acidity that livens the palate, and makes the cherry, cola, red currant and mocha flavors vibrant. Could develop additional bottle complexities, but it’s so silky and elegant, it’s probably at its best now and for a couple years.——S.H.(7/1/2008)—— 89